Just A Bit
January 23rd, 2008 January 23rd, 2008 Posted in Open SourceNo Comments »
Short in the wireless department; if Ubuntu had it there I would look no further–the present state of wireless support (as of Gutsy Gibbon 7.10) is simply not up to the standard of some of the other ‘major’ distros, namely Suse and Mandriva.
For security, package management, stability and support Ubuntu is by far the leader, though that counts for little when you are on the road and just have to connect wirelessly–watching the network manager applet endlessly spinning its wheels, or watching the terminal return no dhcpoffers –sleeping when you know that it is a viable AP can create no end of frustration.
A couple of weeks ago I installed Mandriva ‘One’ on my test machine (a Thinkpad) with an all localized set up to show how easy it could be done for those less familiar with Linux. They were duly impressed, and a couple of them even considered switching, trying livecd’s that I had burned and given them.
The nice thing about the Mandriva distribution is that wireless support is superb–wirelessly connecting as I start up, and something that those I was demonstrating for could not even get going in their native ##windows installs. That went well, but keeping a non-English system around for daily use was just not in the cards. Got the latest from PCLinuxOS, the MiniME install, and started up from it. Again the wireless was easy to connect, so I went ahead and installed over the Mandriva. As the installer gave me the choice as what I wanted to keep, I chose to only overwrite the Mandriva portion, leaving my home intact. the significant bit here was that I had not set aside a /home partition yet was still able to save all my files and settings.
The minimal install of MiniME meant that the system was quite frisky–if this was going to be a daily use computer then I would stick with Ubuntu–but as I need the wireless at this point that is just not an option. Very hopeful that Hardy Heron will fix all that, but for now will stick with what works best for this machine and what it is used for.
This is after breaking any number of installs and learning how to fix them via forums, searching the internet for fixes, printing out the instructions and generally understanding a bit more on how to recover when things go wrong. As I did a fair amount of research before buying this (now) test machine I was confident that it was well supported in Linux, something that someone converting a longtime ##windows machine may not be able to do so effortlessly.
If you are able to have a daily use computer as well as an older test machine to dabble with, this is one of the best way to introduce yourself to the different package management systems, figure out which system suits your needs best in terms of how easy it is to add codecs and whatnot (wireless, graphics cards, etc); there are some nice surprises out there and they are all free for a test run should you choose to do so. Burn a live cd, try it out, and see what you think. Stay ahead of the curve and try some open source software–it is only going to get better.